Academia.eduAcademia.edu
Smart grid development in India: Separating promises from messy reality Dr. Suyash Jolly KTH Higher Seminar: 24 th October 2016 What is a smart grid ? "Smart Grid" is today used as a marketing term, rather than a technical definition. For this reason there is no well defined and commonly accepted scope of what "smart" is and what it is not. ’’ (International Electrotechnical Commission) Summary of the presentation Hype associated with smart grids but small and slow steps towards implementation (Promises vs messy reality !!) Smart grids seem infeasible and challenging at the moment but there is a need to avoid “Parmenides Fallacy” Events are important avenues for looking at multiple narratives associated with emerging innovation: Case of India Smart Grid Week 2016 Status of the research paper Basic draft outlining the main motivation, theoretical framework and data analysis Need for sharpening the arguments in the paper and more detailed data analysis Theoretical contribution of paper: Impact of event on emergence of development of novel technological fields Structure of the presentation Background of the research project and papers Promises of smart grids and messy reality Data collection and field research in India Discussion of the research paper Conclusion Background of the project STandUP for Energy (Stockholm and Uppsala for Energy): Consortium of researcher working on different issues related to transition to sustainable energy system in Sweden Importance of social and institutional dimensions of smart grids and relevance of Indian market for Swedish stakeholders Theoretical background of the project Institutional theory and organizational institutionalism Sustainability Transitions Demonstration and pilot projects (Innovation Studies) Science, Technology and Society Studies (STS) Research papers in the project Between promising narratives and incremental changes: Exploring the role of the ‘‘Indian smart grid conference ” in implementing smart grids From multiple promises to implementation bottlenecks: lessons from ongoing smart grid demonstration projects in India Smart grids as a panacea for problems in the Indian energy sector: A historical examination of the Indian energy sector (1945-2016) and the recent hype around smart grids Sociotechnological imaginaries New technologies emergence as a result of their existence as images, expectations, and visions Portrayal of distant future in roadmaps and policy documents Actors project a promising technological future and secure resources as well as influence policy priorities for them Multiple promises associated with smart grids Energy security and emission reduction Reducing aggregate technical and commercial losses (India has one of the highest losses in the world) Improving power quality and availability for consumers Reducing power theft and improving efficiency of utilities Improving energy access Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition SCADA Messy reality of smart grids Gimick, clever marketing idea or a clear roadmap for systemic transformation of energy systems Are the promises being actually realised and how are consumers being really benefitted ? Increasing consumer backlash around smart meters, costs, ethical and privacy concerns in the western world Confusion: Not implementing smart grids now might make the situation worse in future Congested electricity grids in India Source: Tongia, 2014, pp 489, picture by Marcus Forrell Situation in Indian city Kolkatta Current reality of electricity grids in India Smart grid development in India One of the largest potential market for smart grids in the world and potential for energy transitions at massive scale Increasing international attention due to massive scale Potential of smart grids for reducing aggregate technical and commercial losses, improving power quality and supply, reducing power theft and enhancing energy access Huge expectations but limited developments on ground Gradual emergence of smart grids in India 2001: APDRP (Accelerated Power Development and Reforms Programme) 2003: Indian Electricity Act 2008: R-APDRP (Restructured Accelerated Power Development and Reforms Programme) 2011: Formation of India Smart Grid Task Force and India smart grid forum 2013: Smart grid vision and roadmap document by Ministry of Power and launch of National Smart Grid Mission 2014: Integrated power development scheme 2015: First international conference cum exhibition on smart grids i.e. India Smart Grid Week 2016: Model regulations for smart grids by Forum of Regulators Data collection efforts Archival data (March 2016 till October 2016) Participant and ethnographic observations in conferences (March 2016) Semi-structured interviews with smart grid experts in India (August 2016) Field research in India Field research in March 2016 in Indian Smart Grid Conference Field research in August 2016 in New Delhi, Mysore Semi-structured interviews with Indian smart grid experts Live smart grid demonstration in CESC Mysore Challenges involved in conducting interviews Multiple interview requests send in June and July before going to India Requests send again but few responses and interviewees not giving a confirmed response Personal phone calls also declined multiple times and postponing of interviews Limited avenues for collection of rich empirical data from practitioners Study of smart grid pilot projects Multiple pilot projects currently being implemented 5 projects studied and analyzed Projects chosen with different criteria: Main actor (Government utility, private utility, private company), stakeholder network (national and international),smart grid functionality Projects require more time to show concrete results and consumer engagement Discussion of research paper Between promising narratives and incremental changes: Exploring the role of the ‘‘Indian smart grid conference” in implementing smart grids Research question What role do events such as India smart grid week play in facilitating multiple discourses around smart grids and what is the eventual impact of the events on smart grid deployment ? Field configuring events “ Field-Configuring Events (FCEs) are temporary social organizations such as tradeshows, professional gatherings, technology contests, and business ceremonies that encapsulate and shape the development of professions, technologies, markets, and industries. They are settings in which people from diverse organizations and with diverse purposes assemble periodically, or on a one-time basis, to announce new products, develop industry standards, construct social networks, recognize accomplishments, share and interpret information, and transact business ” (Lampel & Meyer, 2008; pp 1026) Discourses and FCE’s Competing actor groups impose their solutions for ongoing issues and secure their interests Struggle between competing narratives with the purpose of arriving at consensus for moving forward Narratives which dominate during events lead to new rules Field configuring or Field maintaining Different kind of events with different motivations and purpose Difficulties in categorizing the term field configuring to an event before hand as many events turn into field reproducing Impact of the events in terms of radical changes is uncertain and difficult to establish (Cause and effect relationship) Business conferences and trade shows Decentralized knowledge exchange apart from debates and discussions on specific pre-defined themes Trade and new business opportunities and learning about best practices Avenues for showcasing latest technologies and solutions and assessing competition in the market Case study: Indian smart grid week Prominent smart grid conference and exhibition in India organized by India Smart Grid Forum held in March 2016 in New Delhi First event organized in March 2015 and next event to be organized in March 2017 Event aimed at bringing relevant stakeholders for smart grids together and differentiating from other competing events with limited interest in supporting smart grids Different sessions on various aspects of smart grids (i.e. projects, business models, regulations and policy, standards etc.) for implementation of smart grids Organizer: India Smart Grid Forum Public-private partnership by Ministry of Power for implementing smart grids Creation of platform for implementing and deploying smart grid technologies in a cost effective and scalable manner Activities from trade events helping in attracting participants and sponsoring the conference activities Statistics of ISGW 2015 700 participants 94 International and Indian speakers and 36 exhibitors Participation from 27 utilities Statistics of ISGW 2016 1500 participants with representation from 33 countries 203 speakers and 54 exhibitors Participation by 50 utilities Support from international organizations such as IEEE, ISGN, EU Commission, GSGF, USTDA, US Chamber of Commerce etc Event sponsored by Swedish Government “ Our companies and institutions are placed well to contribute towards India's economic growth and social objectives. Sweden is determined to remain leader in smart grids. Swedish firms are being seen as long term partners for development. India and Sweden are far apart and are different countries but share common challenges and see important possibilities for cooperation and complementarities with respect to energy transition. India and Sweden look forward to cooperation and Sweden is proud to be supporters of India smart grid week ” (Swedish Ambassador in India Harald Sandberg) Stakeholder discussions during the conference Swedish companies with interest in Indian market Informal conversations during the event Development of new business linkages Trade show with different exhibitors Indian Minister of Power during the event Research method Field notes prepared during the conference Observations during the conferences including video recordings Interview with conference organizers Archival data such as published reports and articles YouTube videos of the event Key narratives during the event Ambiguity about real purpose of smart grids Lessons learned from ongoing pilot and demonstration projects with limited success so far Cost impact on ordinary consumers while implementing smart grids Few outcomes of the event Creation of new expectations and visions for large scale implementation of smart grids in India (e.g. vision for roll out of 250 million smart meters at INR 999 by 2019 by Minister of Power Piyush Goyal) Smart grid paper highlighting cost benefit analysis, standards, business models and roll out strategy for AMI meters for consumers on a feeder level Collective learning and new business opportunities for participants Momentum around smart grids Gradual development of a smart grid sector with support from domestic and international networks Increase in buzz and activities around smart grids in India and new opportunities for different actors Debates and learning on essential bottlenecks around implementation of smart grids Experiences of participants Using the forum and event to showcase solutions to visitors and take advantage for new business opportunities Unique platforum for showcasing state of art technology and showcasing how smart grid can work in Indian context Evaluating the experiences of the event and deciding about participating in the next conference in 2017 Conclusion Conceptualizing the emergence of smart grids using insights from FCE and business conference literature Anticipation around smart grids and multiple discourses surrounding them Events also trigger the gradual development of novel technological fields such as smart grids “There are risks and costs to a program of action. But they are far less than the long range risks and costs of comfortable inaction.” John F Kennedy Source: goo.gl/WOb9hK Thank you for your time and attention !! Questions and suggestions !