Please note that some posts contains affiliate links & I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links Find out More

Cat Litter Box Problems? 9 Reasons Cats Snub the Box & What To Do

by | Mar 27, 2024 | Cat Behavior & Care | 6 comments

Cat litter box problems pose the number one reason cats lose their homes and end up in animal shelters. Do you need to learn how to stop cats from peeing in house? That’s also the top reason an adopted kitten or cat gets returned. How sad! It’s important to keep in mind ways to prevent litter box problems from the moment you bring home the new kitten.

Fortunately, Trinity-Kitten immediately understood what to do with her litter. And so far, we’ve had no problems with her–or with Karma-Kat as they learn to live together.

People want cats to stop peeing on the carpet, pooping outside the litter box, and spraying urine — especially peeing on your bed! But there is no single reason for hit-or-miss potty problems, and therefore, no single “cure” for bad behavior, but you can find out what to do with these common reasons cats snub the box. Note: I added one, in honor of Shadow-Pup!

litter box problems
Too many sharing one potty is a recipe for failure!

Folks generally assume that any litter box issue is due to a behavior problem, but you CANNOT separate health from behavior. The two go together like … like… laps and cats, or kittens and toys. Here are a few of the many reasons cats snub the litter box and develop litter box problems.

Why Cats Have Litter Box Problems

Clueless Kittens. Your new baby does not come pre-programmed knowing what to do. Even if she copy-cat’d her mother’s behavior, a kitten may not know where the facilities are located, or be able to reach them in time. Make it easy for new kittens. For the first week or so, confine her in one room with a nearby litter box (and other kitty equipment) so she learns allegiance to the box. Put her in the box and praise when she’s productive. Learn more about training your kitten to use the litter box at this link.

Clueless Adults. Adult cats certainly know how to “go” but your home is new territory for them. Be sure the adopted cat knows where to find the litter boxes. Find out what type of litter pan and box filler the shelter used, and start out with the same kind (you can transition latter, if need be). If he’s previously been an outdoor cat, he may not recognize the litter pan as the toilet. Give him a clue: add a top-dusting of potting soil or leaves from outside.

Marking Territory.  If you want to stop your cats from spraying, it’s important to understand why they do it. To cats, urine holds more fascinating, important information than my Kindle. Intact felines (both boys and girls) use urine like Match.com to advertise their availability and to cow interlopers from trespassing. Getting your cat spayed or neutered prior to sexual maturity reduces urine marking up to 90+ percent. So don’t wait!

SerenKarma
Seren learned to tolerate Karma, but his pestering led to litter box challenges. Image copr. Amy Shojai, CABC

Other Cats. Having to share potties puts many cats’ tails in a twist. Do YOU want to “go” after someone else? Didn’t think so. ;P Even when properly introduced, some cats want one box for solids and another for liquids. By age 19, Seren was not been happy about the interloper, Karma, and for the first time Seren started going outside the box. She found a spot behind a big chair, hidden from Karma but with two-way access, and left her “deposits” there. So…I got another litter box, cleaned the carpet thoroughly, and installed the new potty where she wanted it.

Rude Dogs. With the new puppy in our lives, Karma-Kat’s comfort means managing Shadow’s access to cat territory, including the litter box. We properly introduced them, and they respect and show interest in each other. The pup, confined to the kitchen, can’t reach Karma’s facilities in the laundry room because of the pet gate barrier. It’s not unusual, though, for dogs to invade or even snack from litter boxes and that prompts kitty to find other places to “go.” And a few dogs want to copy-cat the behavior and the dog uses the cat litter box and hisses off the kitty owner.

Old Cats. As Seren-Kitty grew older, it became more difficult for her to get to the facilities on time. She also suffered from arthritis that made it hard to climb in and out of the litter box. These are not unusual problems for old cats. We offered her a litter box with lower sides, and eventually, provided “puppy pads” for her so she had more opportunity to relieve herself in a hygienic way. She nearly lived to be 22 years old, so Seren deserved every bit of help possible.

Making sure there are enough litter boxes reduces the competition so one top cat doesn’t guard the bathroom and prevent others from accessing it. I recommend the 1+1 rule: one box, per cat, plus one. The stress of other cats also can prompt urine marking, not just to claim territory, but to use self-scent to calm their frazzled kitty nerves.

Smelly Box. Keeping the toilet clean seems to be a no-brainer, but you’d be surprised how quickly the yucky stuff builds up. Get the cleanup on a schedule. Daily, no exceptions, will reduce the chance of lapses. And “smelly” may also mean “too perfume-y” according to your cat, so beware of strongly scented box fillers, too.

Changing Litter. Once your cat swears allegiance to a particular type of litter, think long and hard about switching it out. Some cats won’t mind, but others have very specific preferences. Make changes slowly–offering the “old” standard alongside a box of the “new” litter, to introduce the notion. Only once your cat has routinely used the “new” substrate should you consider eliminating the old one.

I’m often offered products to test with my pets, like this new FlushIt plant-based litter from Shichic. I’ve not yet had a chance to allow the kitties to test, but here’s what the company says:

  • FlushIt contains 100% organic ingredients like tofu soybean pulp, cornstarch, guar gum, and a bouquet of nature’s finest for cats—rose petals, chamomile, and valerian roots. The ingredients are 100% biodegradable allowing you to safely flush small quantities down the toilet. (Please do check this with your local regulations!)
  • Up to 4x lighter than traditional clay litter
  • Soft texture is a treat for tender paws,
  • Comes as pelleted; or crushed (strong clumping) versions–crushed works in auto-litter boxes.

(I am NOT being compensated for sharing this information, but feel it may be of value and interest to you. Please look further into the product at the website noted above. Learn more about cat litter here.)

cat litter box problems
A tiny box can throw off your cat’s litter box aim.

Bad Facilities. Every cat is unique so what works for one may be awful for the next. Bad facilities may include a poor location, type of box, or kind of box filler.

  • Cats want privacy, but don’t want to feel trapped. Avoid placement in corners of rooms, or underneath cabinets, for instance. Locations that have a good lookout (so they can see the other cats coming and escape!) are ideal.
  • Most cats prefer soft, sandy textures easy on the paws for digging. They also like routine. So once you’ve found something they use faithfully, don’t mess with success.
  • Many commercial boxes are too small, and covered boxes contain odors and may make cats feel trapped. Experiment by offering a variety to see what your cat prefers. I like the translucent storage boxes from container stores, because they’re bigger for jumbo-size squatters, and the cat can see other cats approach.

Separation Anxiety. Yes, cats can be lonely and stressed when their routine changes and you work longer hours, for instance. One of the major signs is the cat peeing on your bed. Learn about kitty separation anxiety here.

Dirty Litter Box Accidents

  • Clean soiled areas thoroughly or the scent will draw Sheba (even innocent bystanders!) back to the scene of the crime. Avoid using ammonia-based products, which cats think smells like the ammonia in their own urine.
  • To find hidden urine accidents, invest in a quality “black light” and shine it around after you’ve turned off lights in the suspect areas. Cat urine glows under the black light. Here’s a black light kit designed for finding litter-ary mistakes!
  • If your cats target plastic or rubber-backed bath mats, toss out the mats. The backing hosts various microorganisms designed to keep the carpet stain-resistant, but it smells like urine to cats, and many felines eliminate on these mats because they already smell like a litter box.

Litter Box Problems & Health Issues

When your cat has been faithful to the potty and suddenly develops problems, your veterinarian should be the first call. There are a number of health issues that may underlie the cat’s litter box lapses, including Feline Lower Urinary Tract disorders.

Painful urination or defecation may result in the cat “blaming” the box for the for the discomfort. When kitty hates the box, she’ll look elsewhere for a comfy spot to go–like under your potted palm.

Buy a new box. Plastic holds odor and smelly old boxes offend cats even when you’ve scrubbed them. Cats that “blame” the old box for a scare or discomfort often eagerly embrace a new facility.

The proper diagnosis from your vet is vital in order to treat and often reverse the condition and poor behavior. Some signs of possible health conditions include any one or combination of the following:

  • break in house training
  • dribbling urine
  • straining in the litter box
  • Spending lots of time “posing” with little result
  • bloody urine or urine with a strong ammonia smell
  • crying during elimination
  • excessively licking the genitals
  • Some cats “go” in the sink or bathtub, or squat right in front of you (asking for help?)

So what about your cats? Have you had litter box challenges? Do tell! Watch the Ask Amy video below for another issue and tips.

Learn where you can find professional pet behavior help in this post.

I love hearing from you, so please share comments and questions. Do you have an ASK AMY question you’d like answered? Do you have a new kitten and need answers? Stay up to date on all the latest just subscribe the blog, “like” me on Facebook, and sign up for Pet Peeves newsletter.

Stay up to date with the latest book giveaways and appearances related to my September Day pet-centric THRILLERS WITH BITE!  Amy Shojai, CABC is a certified cat & dog behavior consultant, a consultant to the pet industry, and the award-winning author of 35+ pet-centric books and Thrillers with Bite! Oh, and she loves bling!

6 Comments

  1. ERIC MONTANA

    Hello Amy,

    Eric Montana here, and I must say, your recent blog post on “Litter Box Problems” had me both nodding in agreement and chuckling at the relatable anecdotes you shared. As a fellow feline enthusiast and someone who appreciates a well-kept home, your insights resonated deeply with me.

    Your comprehensive breakdown of the potential reasons behind litter box mishaps demonstrated your expertise in understanding our furry friends’ behavior. Your proactive approach to addressing these issues is commendable. It’s like having a troubleshooting guide that any cat owner can turn to in their time of litter-related despair.

    I particularly enjoyed your witty take on the “litter-ary preferences” of cats. Who would’ve thought our feline companions could be so finicky about their restroom choices? Your storytelling skills not only entertained but also educated, making it easier for readers to grasp the nuances of cat psychology.

    Your suggestion of creating a “feline spa experience” around the litter box truly made me smile. It’s amazing how a little creativity can transform a mundane necessity into an inviting space for our cats. I can already picture our whiskered friends enjoying their private getaway while we marvel at their sophisticated tastes.

    Now, to address the elephant in the room—or should I say, the litter on the floor—your practical tips for dealing with litter scatter are a lifesaver. As someone who’s had their fair share of stepping on tiny granules around the house, I can vouch for the effectiveness of your suggestions. And it’s moments like these when I’m grateful for experts like you who make cat ownership a joyous experience.

    Amy, your blog post not only provided valuable solutions but also created a sense of camaraderie among cat owners who share similar struggles. It’s reassuring to know that someone out there understands the quirks of our four-legged companions and offers actionable advice with a dash of humor.

    Thank you for your dedication to enhancing the lives of cats and their human companions. Your blog post has earned a spot in my bookmarks, and I’ll be sure to share it with my fellow cat enthusiasts. Keep up the fantastic work!

    Wishing you and your furry muses all the best,

    Eric Montana
    [Obsession with Options]

    Reply
  2. Aimable Cats

    A couple of reasons I’ve seen…

    Kitty had a view of the back door when using his box and was surprised by a visitor. I’d say it scared the crap out of him but…

    Parker could not get to the litterbox because of dirty laundry blocking her access, so she peed on the dirty laundry.

    Rico peed in the spilled litter outside the box.

    When the kitty litter froze in the shed, the shed cats stopped using it altogether.

    Reply
    • Amy Shojai

      Awwww… Excellent additions to the list. Be aware of the “outside” view, or by potential interruptions. Sounds like Parker and Rico did the best they could, LOL! And whew, great reminder about outdoor cat box issues and frozen litter. Thanks for the comments!

      Reply
  3. Dylan Peterson

    It’s good to know that vats need privacy while using the litter box. My wife and I would like to get a cat, and we want to make sure that it is comfortable using a litter box so that we don’t have to clean up after it. We’ll be sure to look further into our options for putting the litter box in a private place in the future.

    Reply
  4. Cathy Keisha

    This is great. Informative yet funny.

    Reply
    • Amy Shojai

      Thanks! Ya gotta laugh or else sometimes you’d cry. *s*

      Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Black Cat Appreciation Day: Picking the Perfect CatAMY SHOJAI'S Bling, Bitches & Blood - […] claw etiquette, the rules of the house (staying OFF countertops), and bathroom manners in the litterbox. Kittens and cats…
  2. Scent Enrichment for Cats Relieves Stress, Reduces Behavior ProblemsAMY SHOJAI'S Bling, Bitches & Blood - […] But a restricted indoor lifestyle has negative consequences. Indoor cats must share territory and can’t get away from each…
  3. Why Do Cats Spray and How to Stop Cat Spraying!AMY SHOJAI'S Bling, Bitches & Blood - […] Cats spray urine as a marking behavior. Sprayed urine targets vertical objects. House soiling is urinating downward over horizontal…
  4. Why Do Cats Hate Vacations? Does My Cat Hate Me for Leaving?AMY SHOJAI'S Bling, Bitches & Blood - […] When you return, your cat’s vacation angst makes her want nothing to do with you. She even *gasp* pees…
  5. Dog Uses Cat Litter Box? Yes, You Can Train the Behavior! - […] results in some terrific discussions. We often talk about the most common cat behavior issue–cat litter box problems. I…
  6. Pet Smell? 6 Pet Smell Removers for Pet Potty Accidents - […] are many reasons for pets messing in the house. Learn about hit-or-miss cat litter box problems in this blog…
  7. National Love Your Pet Day: 14 Ways How Pets Show Love - […] Cats scratch and pee to calm themselves down, and seek out items that smell most like their beloved human.…
  8. Cat Separation Anxiety: Causes, Symptoms & What to Do - […] Like dogs with the same condition, cats may cry and become upset as you prepare to leave. More often,…
  9. Tidy Cats Lightweight Litter Saves Your Back: A Review - […] Along the same lines, some cats get so confused they try to “cover” when they’re outside the box. Here’s…
  10. Cat Litter: History of Cat Litter & New Cat Litter Choices - […] litter choices can make or break a kitty-human relationship. Litter box problems plague many cat lovers. What goes in…
  11. Cat Litter Box Training: Ask Amy Video - […] from new kitten owners. Planning ahead can save cat lovers lots of heartache by preventing litter box problems before…
  12. FLUTD & Cat Urinary Stones: What You Need to Know - […] carpet, Sheba cries and squats right in front of you, and bloody urine puddles in the bathtub. Some litter…
  13. Angry Cat? 8 Ways People Hiss Off Cats - […] Litter-ary Woes: Hit-or-miss potty behavior is the top complaint of cat owners—but we bring it on ourselves. Most standard…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories:

Recent Posts

How to Stop Dog Attacks and Prevent Dog Fights

Do you know how to stop dog attacks and prevent dog fights? The tragedy of dog fights result in multiple victims–the injured as well as the aggressor. My heart breaks for all involved. In the past year, two of my Facebook friends have tragically suffered dog attacks. This post offers tips for preventing dog fights and how to stop dog attacks. That prevents dog bite injuries to you and your pets, and also protects owners from liability….

What Is Surrender Prevention? Help Cats & Shelters

Recently I learned about a marvelous program called SURRENDER PREVENTION that seeks to keep cats from going into shelters and losing their homes. This FREE program offers tools and tips for shelter staff not only for shelter adoptions but to keep cats in homes. This lightens the workload, while saving cat lives–and loving relationships, by keeping cats in homes. Learn more about this free program!

DON’T Hug Your Dog on National Hug Your Dog Day! Here’s Why

Several years ago when I wrote for the puppies.about.com site (now TheSprucePets) I took issue with a promotion advertised by a big-name pet food company that encouraged people to post pictures of themselves hugging dogs. Hoo-boy…Oh dear heaven, by the comments I received you’d think that I said cute babies are evil, apple pie is poison and advocated BEATING YOUR DOG! Part of that has to do with folks reading only the title and ignoring the content of the message. Oh well. That drives home the importance of titles, I suppose.

The promo really struck a chord with pet lovers. After all, who doesn’t love a hug? Hugs mean love, hugs mean happy happy happy, hugs are tail-wagging expressions of the joy we share with dogs. Right? RIGHT?!

Uh, no. And glory be, the promotion lives on, declaring September 11 as “Hug Your Hound Day.” Before you tar-and-feather me, read on to learn WHY hugging your dog can put you, and your dog, in danger…

Prevent Pet Fleas, Heartworm, & Tapeworm Parasites Year Round

When it comes to pet parasites, I just want to unleash the FLYING MONKEYS…except they’re liable to be plagued by fleas, too. Even flying monkeys deserve to be pest free, but there are still many pet parents who may not have all the facts about canine intestinal and external parasites and how to kick the bugs out. Fleas also impact skin conditions and can prompt dog allergies. So…how much do YOU know? Learn more here!

Cat Neatness Freaks: How & Why Cats Groom

Does your cat groom nonstop? We cherish the cat’s fastidious nature but did you ever wonder why cats groom? Neatnik behavior goes beyond looking good. Did you know in this hot weather, cats also groom to stay cool and prevent heatstroke? 

How and why cats groom impacts physical, emotional, and social health. My Karma-Kat even tries to groom his best friend, Bravo-Dawg. The instinct starts during kittenhood and lasts a lifetime. Of course, some cats get dingy when cats don’t groom, and there are reasons for that as well.

Grooming is a barometer of kitty health. Cats that feel bad often stop grooming, or lick and pull fur out due to stress or pain. Consider an unthrifty appearance or “barbering” themselves bald a kitty cry for vet care. Cats often need help in the grooming department—especially longhair beauties. Here are 5 common reasons why cats groom.

Is Your Puppy Chewing? Here’s 8 Tips How To Stop Dog Chewing

Chewing is normal behavior for dogs—and for some cats. You can’t stop dog chewing, and shouldn’t try. Puppies and kittens test their world the same way human infants do. Everything goes into the mouth. Teething youngsters chew objects to relieve the discomfort, but adult dogs rarely outgrow the habit the way (we hope!) people do.

I last wrote about canine chewing when Bravo came to live with us as a new pup. He chewed everything within reach (Oh, my poor coffee table!), including chew toys. We still have Magic-markers on the baseboard and plaster from our last beloved dog. Now we have to re-do flooring in the laundry room, courtesy of Bravo-Dawg.

These days, we THINK we have a handle on Shadow-Pup. We have to really watch him, though, because Shadow likes to chew sticks–yikes!–and has already got one piece caught across the roof of his mouth. When you have a baby-dawg, or even adult canines, it can be a constant struggle to monitor them for safe chewing.

Top 10 Puppy Proofing Tips to Save Dog Lives

When you have a puppy, every day is puppy day, with puppy proofing a requirement. Whether you plan to adopt a puppy, or already live with a cute puppy-kid, it’s important to know the top puppy proofing tips to save dog lives. Loving a puppy goes beyond teaching them where and when to potty. When  Shadow-Pup showed up at our house, we revisited all the must-know puppy issues!

If you know someone with a new furry wonder, I hope you’ll consider “gifting” them with all the info they need with a copy of my book COMPLETE PUPPY CARE.

WHAT IS PUPPY PROOFING?

Puppy proofing is the canine version of human baby-proofing when a new bundle of joy arrives. It’s vital you know how to puppy proof your home and yard. Puppies explore their world with nose pokes, paw pounces, and chewing everything within reach throughout their development stages…

Visit Amy's Website

Amy Shojai CACB is an award winning author.  You can find all her publications and book her to speak via her website. 

On Demand Writer Coaching

AmyShojai.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com http://amazon.com/.

Awards

Memberships